Urban Agglomerations: Approaches to the Allocation and Delimitation

Currently, Russia has declared the need to develop a federal law “On urban agglomerations”; the development of urban agglomerations is declared as a necessary condition for ensuring economic growth and innovative development in the country. However, there are no evident approaches to the allocation and delimitation of urban agglomerations; the definitions given in the Russian spatial development strategy are very general. In this regard, the purpose of this article is to summarize the existing approaches to working with agglomerations in foreign and Russian science and practice. The article shows that in economically developed countries, the main approach to the allocation of agglomerations is functional, in which the area of interaction between the “core” of the agglomeration and its “hinterland” is determined, first of all, by the intensity of pendulum labor migrations; the functional approach is gradually transformed into a network approach, implying the polycentricity of agglomerations. The allocation and delimitation of agglomerations in a country can be based on a unified or individual approach. The article suggests using both options in Russia: a unified approach for improving statistical accounting of changes in the settlement system, which is close to the OECD methodology, and an individual approach for strategic planning and development of inter-municipal cooperation. The advantage of the OECD methodology is that there is no need to rely on the existing territorial boundaries of local self-government, which differ markedly across the subjects of the Russian Federation. It is also proposed to conduct a broad discussion of the approaches to the allocation and delimitation of agglomerations for the law “On urban agglomerations”; to improve the system of statistical accounting for pendulum population migrations, including in population censuses.

allocation and delimitation of urban agglomerations, core and periphery of the agglomeration, metropolitan and urbanized areas, administrative-territorial division grid, intensity of pendulum migrations, statistical accounting, inter-municipal cooperation, strategic planning

1. Standards for Delineating Metropolitan and Micropolitan Statistical Areas; Notice (2010). Federal Register, vol. 75, no 123. Available at: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/06/28/2010-15605/2010-standards-for-delineating-metropolitan-andmicropolitan-statistical-areas, accessed 20.02.2019.

2. Agglomerations of Canada. Development of Urban Agglomerations. Issue 2. Russian Institute of Urban Planning and Investment Development “Giprogor”. Available at: http://giprogor.ru/sites/default/files/Развитие%20городских%20агломераций%20-%20аналитический%20обзор.%20Выпуск%202.pdf, accessed 03.03.2019.

3. Averkieva K.V., Antonov E.V., Denisov E.A., Faddeev A.M. (2015) Territorial Structure of the Urban System in the Northern Sverdlovsk Oblast. Regional Research of Russia, vol. 5, no 4, pp. 349–361 (in Russian). DOI: 10.15356/0373-2444-2015-4-24-38

4. Boix R., Veneri P., Almenar V. (2012) Polycentric Metropolitan Areas in Europe: Towards a Unified Proposal of Delimitation. Defining the Spatial Scale in Modern Regional Analysis. Advances in Spatial Science (The Regional Science Series) (eds. Fernández Vázquez E., Rubiera Morollón F.), Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 45– 70. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-31994-5_3

5. Brezzi M., Piacentini M., Sanchez-Serra D. (2012) Measuring Metropolitan Areas: A Comparative Approach in OECD Countries. Defining the Spatial Scale in Modern Regional Analysis. Advances in Spatial Science (The Regional Science Series) (eds. Fernández Vázquez E., Rubiera Morollón F.), Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 71– 89. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-31994-5_4

6. Bur’yan A.P. (1973) Delimitation of Urban Agglomerations (on the Example of the Chelyabinsk Agglomeration). Scientific Notes of the Gorky Perm University. Issue 311, Perm, pp. 44–53 (in Russian).

7. Cheshire P., Magrini S. (2008) Urban Growth Drivers in a Europe of Sticky People and Implicit Boundaries. Journal of Economic Geography, vol. 9, no 1, pp. 85– 115. DOI: 10.1093/jeg/lbn044

8. Chugunova N.V. (2014) The Belgorod Agglomeration in the Regional Settlement System. Upravlenie gorodom: teoriya i praktika, no 1(12), pp. 30–36. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_21791063_59016549.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian). CMA and CA: Detailed Definition. Statistics Canada Service. Available at: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/92-195-x/2011001/geo/cma-rmr/def-eng.htm, accessed 21.04.2020.

9. Consiglio dei Ministri La Statistica per le Aree Metropolitane e Sulle Aree Metropolitane: Proposta per un Sistema Informativo Integrato (2006). Rapporto di Indagine 06.2, Roma: Presidenza del Consiglio dei Ministri.

10. Davidovich V.G. (1964) Urban Agglomerations in the USSR. Main Issues of Economic Geography. Materials for the IV Congress of the USSR. Symposium “B”. Reports. Part I. Leningrad, pp. 34–47 (in Russian). Davidovich V.G. (1967) On Interconnected Settlement in Urban Agglomerations. To Help a City Planner. Issue 7, Kiev, pp. 32–35 (in Russian).

11. Decree of the President of the Russian Federation dated 16.01.2017 no 13 “On Approval of the State Policy of Regional Development of the Russian Federation for the Period up to 2025”. President of Russian Federation. Available at: http://www.kremlin.ru/acts/bank/41641, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

12. Definition of Functional Urban Areas (FUA) for the OECD metropolitan database (2013). OECD. Available at: https://www.oecd.org/cfe/regional-policy/Definition-of-Functional-Urban-Areasfor-the-OECD-metropolitan-database.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020.

13. Designing Space for the Future. Development of Urban Agglomerations. Issue 2. Russian Institute of Urban Planning and Investment Development “Giprogor”. Available at: http://www.giprogor.ru/sites/default/files/Giprogor_Preview.pdf, accessed 03.03.2019 (in Russian).

14. Development of Urban Agglomerations. Development of Urban Agglomerations. Issue 2. Russian Institute of Urban Planning and Investment Development “Giprogor”. Available at: http://giprogor.ru/sites/default/files/Развитие%20городских%20агломераций%20-%20аналитический%20обзор.%20Выпуск%202.pdf, accessed 03.03.2019 (in Russian).

15. Fedorova E.N., Ponomareva G.A. (2014) Aspects of Agglomeration Development of Yakutsk. Economic Analysis: Theory and Practice, no 39(391), pp. 18–25. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/aspekty-aglomeratsionnogo-razvitiya-yakutska/viewer, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

16. Fomin I.A. (1968) Quantitative Characteristics of Urban Agglomerations. City Building. District Planning. Urban Agglomeration, Kiev (in Russian).

17. Freeman A. (2005) Towards a Common Standard: Comparing European and American Cities. MPRA Paper, No 18104. Available at: https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/18104/1/MPRA_paper_18104.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020.

18. Fujita M., Krugman P. (2004) The New Economic Geography. Past, Present and the Future. Fifty Years of Regional Science. Advances in Spatial Science (eds. Florax R.J.G.M., Plane D.A.), Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 139–164.

19. Fujita M., Krugman P., Venables A. (1999) The Spatial Economy: Cities, Regions and International Trade, Сambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.

20. Glazychev V.L., Starodubrovskaya I.V. (2008) Chelyabinsk Agglomeration: Development Potential, Chelyabinsk (in Russian).

21. Gokhman V.M., Kostinitskij G.D. (1979) Features of Urbanization and Settlement Trends in Western Europe. Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences, no 5, pp. 78–91 (in Russian).

22. Graf I.V., Zharomskikh D.G. (2006) Inter-municipal Economic Cooperation: Experience of Legal Regulation in Foreign Countries. Bulletin of the Tyumen State University. Socio-economic and Legal Research, no 1, pp. 150–156. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_9208126_60834786.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

23. Gudzhiabidze V.V. (1983) Urban Agglomerations of Georgia (the Problem of Delimitation of Large Urban Agglomerations). Problems of Population Geography and Spatial Organization, Tbilisi, pp. 132– 174 (in Russian).

24. Izhguzina N.R. (2014) Approaches to the Delimitation of the Urban Agglomerations. Discussion, no 9(50), pp. 44– 52. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/podhody-k-delimitatsii-gorodskih-aglomeratsiy/viewer, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

25. Kalashnikova O.G. (2015) Agglomeration Effects in the Creation and Management of Agglomerations. City Management: Theory and Practice, no 3, pp. 40– 46. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/aglomeratsionnye-effekty-prisozdanii-i-upravlenii-aglomeratsiey/viewer, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

26. Kashin A.A., Kudryavtsev A.F., Lekomtsev A.L. (2016) Izhevsk Agglomeration: Geo-economic Analysis. Chasopis ekonomichnikh reform, no 4(24), pp. 100– 107 (in Russian).

27. Kharitonova V.M. (1968) To Determining the Boundaries of the Conurbation. VMU, no 4, pp. 91–98 (in Russian).

28. Khodzhaev D.G. (1970) Some Problems of Regulating the Growth and Development of Localities. To Help a City Planner. Issue 1, Kiev (in Russian).

29. Klapka P., Halas M. (2016) Conceptualising Patterns of Spatial Flows: Five Decades of Advances in the Definition and Use of Functional Regions. Moravian Geographical Reports, vol. 24, no 2, pp. 2–11. DOI: 10.1515/mgr-2016-0006

30. Knapp W., Schmitt P. (2003) Re-structuring Competitive Metropolitan Regions in North-west Europe: On Territory and Governance. European Journal of Spatial Development, no 6. Available at: https://archive.nordregio.se/Global/Publications/Publications%202017/Refereed_6_Knapp(2003).pdf, accessed 21.04.2020.

31. Kuznetsova O.V. (2019) Settlement Transformation and the Problems of Its Adequate Consideration in the Spatial Development Strategy. Population and Economics, no 3(1), pp. 53–62. DOI: 10.3897/popecon.3.e34777

32. Lappo G.M. (1978) Development of Urban Agglomerations in the USSR, Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

33. Lappo G.M., Polyan P.M., Selivanova T.V. (2007) Agglomerations of Russia in the XXI Century. Bulletin of the Irkutsk Regional Development Fund, no 1, pp. 45–52. Available at: http://www.frrio.ru/uploads_files/Lappo.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

34. Lappo G.M., Polyan P.M., Selivanova T.V. (2010) Urban Agglomerations of Russia. Demoscope Weekly, no 407–408. Available at: http://www.demoscope.ru/weekly/2010/0407/tema01.php, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

35. Lejzerovich E.E. (1990) Economic Districts of the USSR (Experience of Typological Research), Moscow (in Russian).

36. Lejzerovich E.E. (2004) Economic Districts of Russia (Grid and Typology), Moscow: Trilobite (in Russian).

37. Liang J., Li F., Mao L. (2010) Review of the Methods of Delimitation for the Spatial Scope of Urban Agglomeration. 18th International Conference on Geoinformatics, Beijing, pp. 1–10. DOI: 10.1109/GEOINFORMATICS.2010.5567776

38. Listengurt F.M. (1975) Criteria for Allocation of Large-scale Agglomerations in the USSR. Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences, no 1, pp. 41–49 (in Russian).

39. Lopatnikov L.I. (2003) Economic and Mathematical Dictionary: Dictionary of Modern Economic Science, Moscow: Delo (in Russian).

40. Makhrova A.G. (2013) Urban Agglomeration. Socio-economic Geography: Concepts and Terms. Dictionary-reference (ed. Gorkin A.P.), Smolensk: Ojkumena, p. 74 (in Russian).

41. Melnikova L.V. (2017) City Size, Efficiency and Economic Growth. EKO, no 7, pp. 5–19. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/razmery-gorodov-effektivnost-i-ekonomicheskiy-rost/viewer, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

42. Metodología Utilizada para la Delimitación de las Áreas Urbanas. Las Areas Urbanos (2016). Ministry of Housing of Spain. Available at: https://www.fomento.gob.es/MFOM/LANG_CASTELLANO/_ESPECIALES/SIU/ATLAS, accessed 03.02.2019.

43. Najmark N.I. (1988) Dynamic Typology of Urban Agglomerations of the USSR. Problems in the Study of Urban Agglomerations (eds. Najmark N.I., Zaslavskij I.N.), Moscow (in Russian).

44. Odintsova O.A. (2013) Inter-municipal Cooperation: Lessons of Foreign Ex perience. Federalizm, no 2, pp. 145–158. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_19143418_97919137.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

45. Pertsik E.N. (2009) Large Urban Agglomerations: Development, Design Problems. Problems of Development of Agglomerations in Russia, Moscow: KRASAND, pp. 34–46 (in Russian).

46. Petrov N.V. (1988) Urban Agglomerations: Composition, Approaches to Delimitation. Problems of Territorial Organization of Space and Settlement in Urbanized Areas, Sverdlovsk (in Russian).

47. Pivovarov Yu.L. (1999) Fundamentals of Geo-urbanism: Urbanization and Urban Systems, Moscow: Vlados (in Russian).

48. Plan of Implementation of the Spatial Development Strategy of the Russian Federation for the Period up to 2025. Approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 27, 2019, no 3227- R (2019). Available at: https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/dokumenty/plan_realizacii_strategii_prostranstvennogo_razvitiya_rf_na_period_do_2025_goda.html, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

49. Plan of Legislative Activity of the Government of the Russian Federation for 2020. Approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation no 3205-R of December 26, 2019 (2019). Available at: http://static.government.ru/media/files/ac okCPrAIQ2THkZ3IiuFPUoDdtLWb58h.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

50. Polyan P.M. (1982) Major Urban Agglomerations of the Soviet Union. Proceedings of RGO, vol. 114, no 4, pp. 305–314 (in Russian).

51. Polyan P.M. (1988) Methodology for Selecting and Analyzing the Population Reference Frame, Мoscow: IG RAS (in Russian).

52. Polyan P.M. (2014) Territorial Structures-urbanization – Settlement. Theoretical Approaches and Methods of Study, Мoscow: Novyj Khronograf (in Russian).

53. Polyan P.M., Zaslavskij I.N., Najmark N.I. (1988) The Problem of Delineation of Urban Agglomerations: A Comparison and Synthesis of the Leading Techniques. Problems of Territorial Organization of Space and Settlement in Urbanized Areas, Sverdlovsk (in Russian).

54. Project 3.1 ESPON Atlas: Mapping the Structure of the European Territory (2006). Federal Office for Building and Regional Planning. Available at: https://www.espon.eu/sites/default/files/attachments/Inception_report_ESPON_ATLAS.pdf, accessed 10.02.2019.

55. Rapporto Annuale 2015. La Situazione del Paese. ISTAT (2015). Instituto Nazionale di Statistica. Available at: https://www.istat.it/it/files/2015/05/Rapporto-Annuale-2015.pdf, accessed 20.02.2019.

56. Rejbajn T.Ya. (1) (1974) Influence of Changes in Transport Accessibility on the Formation of Agglomeration Boundaries. Architecture, Planning and Improvement of Localities, Rostov-on-Don (in Russian).

57. Rejbajn T.Ya. (2) (1974) The History of Education of the Rostov Agglomeration. Architecture, Planning and Improvement of Localities, Rostov-on-Don (in Russian).

58. Sergeeva A.S., Burul’ T.N. (2014) On the Issue of Defining the Borders of the Southern Part of the Volgograd Agglomeration. Modern Problems and Ways to Solve Them in Science, Production and Education Journal, no 1(1), pp. 83–87. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_22368864_82944772.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

59. Skutin V.A. (1979) Urban Agglomerations as an Object of Economic and Geographical Research. Placement of Productive Forces in the Urals, Sverdlovsk (in Russian).

60. Smirnyagin L.V. (2009) The Settlement System of Russia: Trends of Change. Demoscope Weekly, no 517–518. Available at: http://www.demoscope.ru/weekly/2012/0517/analit01.php, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

61. Smirnyagin L.V. (2012) Place instead of Location? (On Shifts in Fundamental Concepts of Geography). Geographical Location and Territorial Structures: in Memory of I.M. Maergoiz (ed. Agirrechu A.A.), Мoscow: Novyj Khronograf, pp. 421–456 (in Russian).

62. Sokolov S.N. (2015) Agglomeration Forms of Ugra Settlement. Current Problems of Humanities and Natural Sciences, no 12–8, pp. 55–59. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_25284020_24269540.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

63. Spatial Development Strategy of the Russian Federation for the Period up to 2025. Approved by order of the Government of the Russian Federation dated February 13, 2019, no 207-R (2019). Available at: https://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/72074066/, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

64. Strel’nikov A.I., Semenova O.S. (2010) Variants for Determining the Boundaries of Agglomeration in Modern Conditions Based on the Analysis of Social and Economic Relations and Using Computational Modeling. Transport Business in Russia, no 8, pp. 145–155. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_20137326_82534158.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

65. Strizhkina V.N., Strizhkina I.V. (2015) Some Aspects of the Agglomeration Effect of Major Cities and Towns. Altaj Bulletin of the State and Municipal Service, no 12, pp. 34–37. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_27219039_41371133.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

66. Strongina M.L. (1970) Socio-economic Problems of the Development of Large Cities in the USSR, Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

67. Timirgaleev R.F. (2014) Recent Trends in U.S. Urban Agglomerations. Regional Studies, no 3, pp. 100–107. Available at: https://elibrary.ru/download/elibrary_22487755_35169351.pdf, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

68. Tsykalov V.A., Kuz’menkov K.I. (2016) Peculiarities of the Inter-municipal Cooperation in France. The World of New Economy, no 3, pp. 131–138. Available at: https://wne.fa.ru/jour/article/view/90/91, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

69. Ulyaeva A.G. (2016) Development and Approbation Methods of Determining the Spatial Localization of Agglomeration (on Materials of Republic Bashkortostan). Modern Science: Actual Problems of Theory and Practice, no 10, pp. 48– 54. Available at: www.nauteh-journal.ru/files/74030711-81c9-405a-9ef7-c2cf65b992cb, accessed 21.04.2020 (in Russian).

70. Vishnevskij A.G. (1967) Urban Agglomerations and Economic Regulation of Their Growth (on the Example of the Kharkiv Agglomeration). Abstract PhD thesis in Economic Sciences (in Russian).

71. Zayonchkovskaya Zh.A. (1985) Some Trends in the Evolution of Settlement. Achievements and Prospects. Issue 52, Moscow, pp. 42–51 (in Russian).