The Rise of the Hindu Religious Factor in Indian Politics and State Theory

We are living in an age of reaffirmation and revival of religious/national and cultural identities as a reaction to the sweeping onslaught of socio-economic, cultural and technological globalization. In India the demand for a definition of national identity based on Hinduism or on Hindutva (Hinduness) predates the achievement of independence in 1947 and it was gradually reinforced by successive political crises, such as the partition between India and Pakistan, successive wars with Pakistan, the continuing separatist agitation in the Kashmir Valley and the rise of large-scale Islamist terrorism since the 11th of September 2001 if not before. Historically a distinction has been made between Hinduism, as the religion and way of life of more than a billion people in India and in other countries and Hindutva, a cultural ideology and a sociopolitical doctrine which defines a modernized version of Hindu or in broader sense Indic civilisation (encompassing Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism and other indigenous minority religions). Many Hindus do not accept the premises or least the political theory of Hindutva whereas Hindutva proponents may not be ‘believers’ in the ritual and theological aspects of Hindu Dharma and may define themselves as sceptics, materialists or atheists. However they conceive of the common Hindu national civilisation and millenary historical heritage as the cement that can bind the country’s diverse people together and they usually reject the ‘secular’ view that India is the home of a composite culture forged out of many domestic and foreign elements and consisting of diverse ethnic groups which were brought together as a nation by British colonization. This paper succinctly retraces the evolution and expansion of Hindu nationalism in the politics of the country and distinguishes between the various nuances of the ideology which is now the source of inspiration for the National Democratic Alliance led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. It strives to answer the often asked question: Is India becoming a Hindu State?

India, Hinduism, Dharma, Secularism, Hindutva, Nationalism, Indic, Indian Constitution, Syncretism, J. Nehru, B.R. Ambedkar, Hindu Mashasabha, RSS (Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh), Bharatiya Janata Party, Muslim League, M A Jinnah

1. A Committee Chosen by Modi Government To Rewrite India’s History (2018). NDTV Newsdesk (with inputs from Reuters), March 6, 2018. Available at: https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/a-committee-chosen-by-modi-government-torewrite-indias-history-report-1820397, accessed 20.07.2018.

2. Ambedkar B.R. (1940) Pakistan or The Partition of India, Bombay: Thackers.

3. Constitution of India, 42nd Amendment (1978), Preamble.

4. Dalrymple W. (2006) The Last Mughal, The Fall of a Dynasty. Delhi 1857, New Delhi: Bloomsbury.

5. Dhulipala V. (2013) Towards a New Medina: Jinnah, the Deobandi Ulema and the Quest for Pakistan in late Colonial India, New Delhi.

6. Elst K. (2000) Decolonizing the Hindu Mind – Ideological Development of Hindu Revivalism, New Delhi: Rupa.

7. Elst K. (2001) The Saffron Swastika – The Notion of Hindu Fascism, New Delhi: Rupa.

8. Frawley D. (1998) Awaken Bharata, A Call for India’s Rebirth, New Delhi: Aditya Prakashan.

9. Frawley D. (2010) Universal Hinduism: Towards a New View of Sanathana Dharma, New Delhi: Voice of India.

10. Godse N. (2015) Why I Assassinated Mahatma Gandhi, New Delhi: Hindi Sahitya Sadan.

11. Golwalkar M.S. (1966) Bunch of Thought, New Delhi: Sahitya Sindhu Prakashana.

12. Jahanbegloo R., Bhattacharya N. (2017) Romila Thapar, Talking History, New Delhi: OUP.

13. Jain M. (2010) Parallel Pathways – Essays on Hindu-Muslim Relations, 1707– 1857, New Delhi: Konark.

14. Malhotra R. (2011) Being Different, An Indian Challenge to Western Universalism, New Delhi: Harper Collins.

15. Malhotra R. (2016) Indra’s Net, Defending Hinduism’s Philosophical Unity, New Delhi: Harper Collims.

16. Puranik R. (2016) Nehru’s 97 Major Blunders, New Delhi: Pustak Mahal.

17. Ramaswamy K., Banerjee A. (2007) Invading The Sacred –An Analysis of Hinduism Studies in America, New Delhi: Rupa.

18. Rajan R. (2009) Eclipse of the Hindu Nation – Gandhi and his Freedom Struggle, Kolkata: New Age Publishers.

19. Sarila N.S. (2006) Shadow of the Great Game – The Untold Story of India’s Partition, London: Constable.

20. Savarkar V.D. (1928) Who is a Hindu? New Delhi: Veer Savarkar Prakashan.

21. Sharma A. (2018) Western Concepts and Indian Realities, New Delhi (IIC Additional Publication 84).

22. Singh R.N.P. (2016) Nehru: A Troubled Legacy, New Delhi: Wisdom Tree.

23. Strachey J. (1888) India, Its Administration and Progress, London: MacMillan.

24. Tharoor S. (2018) BJP Planning ‘Major Assault’ on the Constitution. NDTV Newsdesk, February 8, 2018. Available at: https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/bjpplanning-major-assault-on-constitution-shashi-tharoor-1810236, accessed 20.07.2018.

25. Tunzelmann A. von (2007) Indian Summer – The Secret Story of the End of an Empire, New York: Henry Holt and Company.