Constitutional Models of the Principle of Social Justice in African Countries: Comparative Legal Analysis

Based on the comparative legal analysis of the constitutions of African states, the article analyzes the constitutional models of the principle of social justice. The genesis of the Western legal understanding of the principle of social justice, the peculiarities of its reflection in the African legal culture are considered.

Highlighting the Western tradition of the legal understanding of social justice, proceeding from the views of Plato and Aristotle, the author notes that its essence consists in the fair distribution of social benefits based on the achievement of equality. Modern Western legal understanding complements the ancient Greek tradition by considering the conditionality of the principle of social justice by economic and political systems, property relations, social rights and freedoms.

Comparative legal analysis of the constitutions of African states allows the author, on the one hand, to discover similarities in the regulation of the principle of social justice, including under the influence of Western tradition, on the other hand, to see that the constitutions of these countries objectively differ in the degree and nature of taking into account national approaches. In this context, the general and special factors of the national identity of African states that influence the choice of a constitutional model of social justice are highlighted.

The article highlights at least four constitutional models of the principle of social justice on the African continent: liberal-democratic, of socialist orientation, autocratic and hybrid. The autocratic model and especially the hybrid one reflect national identity to a greater extent. At the same time, the number of states with a hybrid model is growing steadily. The article provides a detailed analysis of the constitutional models of the principle of social justice on the example of individual African states, examines the features of the constitutional consolidation of social goals and values, the regulation of social rights and relations on the distribution of income from national wealth.

It is concluded that the classification of constitutional models of the principle of social justice into four groups is gradually losing its relevance. In the future, a hybrid model will be inherent for all African States. The trend of hybridization has clearly emerged at the present time in the practice of constitutional development of African States.

1. Alexandrov Yu.V. (2003). Justice in the system of values of the Russian legal culture. Dissertation ... Candidate of Philos. Sciences: 24.00.01. Veliky Novgorod, 131 pp. (in Russian).

2. Aristotle (2008). Politics. Metaphysics. Analytics. Moscow : Eksmo; St. Petersburg : Midgard, 958 pp. (in Russian).

3. Blount J., Elkins Z., Ginsburg T. (2013). Does the Process of Constitution-Making Matter. In: Ginsburg T. (ed.). Comparative Constitutional Design. Cambridge etc. : Cambridge University Press, pp. 31–65.

4. Bolomatova K. (2022). Ethiopia. Overview of foreign economic activity. Moscow : Agroexport, 34 pp. (in Russian). Available at: http://aemcx.ru/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/, accessed 10.09.2022.

5. Bondar N.S. (2005). Power and freedom on the scales of constitutional justice: protection of human rights by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. Moscow : CJSC Justicinform, 592 pp. (in Russian).

6. Burnell P. (2008). The Relationship of Accountable Governance and Constitutional Implementation, with Reference to Africa. Journal of Politics and Law, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 10–24.

7. Doklad… (2022). Human Development Report 2021/2022. Resume. Uncertain times, unsettled lives: shaping our future in a changing world. New York, UNDP, ix, 31 pp . ( in Russian ). Available at: https ://hdr.undp.org/system/files/documents/global-report-document/hdr2021-22over-viewrupdf.pdf, accessed 10.09.2022.

8. Dworkin R. (2004). About the rights seriously. Moscow : ROSSPAN, 389 pp. (in Russian).

9. Iskenderov P.A. (2019). Economic relations of Russia and African countries: problems and prospects In: Vasiliev A.M., Degterev D.A., Kassae Nygusie V.M. (eds.). Africa in the context of the formation of a new system of international relations: a collection of scientific articles. Moscow : RUDN, pp. 53–67 (in Russian).

10. Ivanova M.G. (2019). Similarities and differences between the archetypes of cultures of African countries and Russia (on the example of Ubuntu philosophy). In: Vasiliev A.M., Degterev D.A., Kassae Nygusie V.M. (eds.). Africa in the context of the formation of a new system of international relations: a collection of scientific articles. Moscow : RUDN, pp. 104–119 (in Russian).

11. Kapto A.S. (2011). Morality in models of the world order. Moscow : East-West, 260 pp. (in Russian).

12. Kassae Nygusie V.M., Saulyak V.E. (2014). Ethnic segmentation of African society at the beginning of the XXI century. Bulletin of the Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia. Series: Political Science, no. 1, pp. 36–40 (in Russian).

13. Kassae Nygusie V.M., Zabella A.A. (2019). Military-technical cooperation of the PRC with African countries. In: Vasiliev A.M., Degterev D.A., Kassae Nygusie V.M. (eds.). Africa in the context of the formation of a new system of international relations: a collection of scientific articles. Moscow : RUDN, pp. 136–146 (in Russian).

14. Kozlov M.I. (2010). Social justice in the context of the Russian tradition. Arkhangelsk : KIRA Publishing House, 201 pp. (in Russian).

15. Krivonogov V.P. (2014). About the ethnic, religious and linguistic composition of the population of the island of Mauritius. Vostok. Afro-Asian Societies: History and Modernity, no. 4, pp. 83–95 (in Russian).

16. Nozik R. (1944). Anarchy, the state and utopia (translation). Abstract Journal. Series 3. Philosophy, no. 4, pp. 149–230 (in Russian).

17. Plato (2007). Essays in four volumes. Vol. 3, part 1. Under the general editorship of A.F. Losev and V.F. Asmus. St. Petersburg : Publishing House of St. Petersburg University, 731 pp. (in Russian).

18. Ramose M. (1999). African Philosophy through Ubuntu. Harare : Mond Books, 208 pp.

19. Rawls D. (2010). Theory of Justice. Translated from English, ed. by V.V. Tselishchev. Moscow : URSS, 534 pp. (in Russian).

20. Rusak N.A., Zakharov A.N., Degterev  D.A. (2019). Chinese investments in the energy sector of Africa. In: Vasiliev A.M., Degterev D.A., Kassae Nygusie V.M. (eds.). Africa in the context of the formation of a new system of international relations: a collection of scientific articles. Moscow : RUDN, pp. 147–157 (in Russian).

21. Timkuk D.A. (2017). Dialogical aspect of African communitarianism in the philosophy of Ubuntu. Sociodynamics, no. 9, pp. 113–122.

22. Vasiliev A., Korendyasov E. (2013). Russian-African relations in ten years: a new start. RIAC, May 22 (in Russian). Available at: http://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-andcomments/analytics/rossiysko-afrikanskie-otnosheniya-cherezdesyat-let-novyy-st/, accessed 10.09.2022.

23. Zorkin V.D. (2011). Constitutional and legal development of Russia. Moscow : Norm, INFRA-M, 720 pp. (in Russian).