Euroscepticism Level of French Parties Determined by the Content-analysis of Their Pre-election Manifestos
https://doi.org/10.23932/2542-0240-2018-11-3-199-212
Abstract
The dynamics of Euroscepticism intensity of some French parties is analysed in the given article with the use of Attitude to European integration index. The degree of criticism of the EU is evaluated quantitatively (1-13 points) based on the following data extracted from 2010-2017 party manifestos: attitude to the principal idea of European integration, affective and instrumental support or discontent of the EU, the perception of the EU as an (un-) accountable institution. The elaborated method was proven to be instrumental and reliable for Euroscepticism studies by finding correspondence between the quantitative values of the Index and Russian scholars’ qualitative estimates. This standardized approach to measurement allowed not only to reveal the general attitude of a particular party towards European integration, but also to compare the obtained estimates with indicators for past years, for other parties, and also in other countries. The developed scale let ascertain some strengthening of National Front’s and J.-L. Melenchon’s supporters’ (nowadays – from “Unbowed France”) Euroscepticism and weakening criticism of the EU by gaullists from the “Union for the Popular Movement” and the “Republicans”. Relatively stronger Euroscepticism of the French Communist Party in comparison to the Socialist Party has been confirmed.
About the Author
A. O. DOMANOV
Institute of Europe of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Address: 2, Nikitskij lane, Moscow, 125009, Russian Federation
Junior Research Fellow
References
1. 144 Engagements Présidentiels. Marine 2017 (2017). Rassemblementnational.fr. Available at: https://www.rassemblementnational.fr/pdf/144-engagements.pdf, accessed 8.03.2018.
2. Basov F.A. (2017) Germaniya v Evropejskom Soyuze: ot ekonomicheskogo lokomotiva k politicheskomu liderstvu [Germany in the European Union: from an Economic Locomotive to Political Leadership]. Outlines of Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, Law, vol. 10, no 1, pp. 33–52.
3. Charte des Socialistes pour le Progrès Humain. Parti-socialiste.fr. Available at: http://www.parti-socialiste.fr/les-socialistes/nos-valeurs/charte-des-socialistes-pour-le-progres-humain/, accessed 8.03.2018.
4. Conti N. (2003) Party Attitudes to European Integration: A Longitudinal Analysis of the Italian Case, Falmer: Sussex European Institute.
5. Easton D. (1965) A Systems Analysis of Political Life, New York: Wiley.
6. Flood C. (2002) Euroscepticism: A Problematic Concept (Illustrated with Reference to France). UACES.org. Available at: http://uaces.org/documents/papers/0201/flood.pdf, accessed 8.03.2018.
7. Gromoglasova E.S., Libman A.M. (2015) Politiko-ekonometricheskij analiz transformatsii partijnykh sistem v Evrosoyuze [Political and Econometric Analysis of Transformations in the EU Party Systems]. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, no 4, pp. 5–17.
8. Kaninskaya G.N. (2009) Chto v imeni tvoem? O frantsuzskikh levykh [What Is in Your Name? On the French Left]. Frantsuzskij ezhegodnik, no 1, pp. 29–53.
9. Kaveshnikov N.Yu., Domanov A.O. (2018) Metodika otsenki evroskepticheskikh nastroenij na primere politicheskikh partij Velikobritanii [A Method for the Evaluation of Eurosceptic Attitudes at the Example of UK Political Parties]. Mezhdunarodnye protsessy (in printing).
10. Klinova M.V. (2017) Ekonomicheskie aspekty programm M. Le Pen i Zh.-L. Melanshona [Economic Aspects of M. Le Pen and J.-L. Melenchon’s Manifestos]. Prezidentskie vybory vo Frantsii-2017 [Presidential Elections in France in 2017] (eds. Klinova M.V., Kudryavtseva A.K., Timofeev P.P.), Moscow: IMEMO RAN, pp. 20–24.
11. La France en Commun. Les Communistes Proposent. PCF.fr. Available at: http://2017.pcf.fr/notre_engagement, accessed 8.03.2018.
12. Le Projet de Marine Le Pen (2012). Web.archive.org. Available at: https://web.archive.org/web/20120418192704/http://www.frontnational.com/le-projet- de-marine-le-pen/, accessed 8.03.2018.
13. L’Humain d’abord (2012). PCF.fr. Available at: http://www.pcf.fr/18549, accessed 8.03.2018.
14. Majorité pour la France. Union de la Droite et du Centre. Projet (2012). Republicains.fr. Available at: https://www.republicains.fr/projet, accessed 8.03.2018.
15. Markowski R., Tucker J. (2007) Political Representation and Euroscepticism: Evidence from Poland. European Elections after Eastern Enlargement: Preliminary Results from the European Election Study 2004 (eds. Marsh M., Mikhaylov S., Schmitt H.), Mannheim: The Connex Report Series, pp. 53–70.
16. Meyer T., Jenny M. (2013) Measuring Error for Adjacent Policy Position Estimates: Dealing with Uncertainty Using CMP Data. Electoral Studies, no 32, pp. 174–185.
17. Naumova N.N. (2017) Osobennosti predvybornoj programmy M. Le Pen-2017 [The Features of M. Le Pen’s Manifesto in 2017]. Prezidentskie vybory vo Frantsii- 2017 [Presidential Elections in France in 2017] (eds. Klinova M.V., Kudryavtseva A.K., Timofeev P.P.), Moscow: IMEMO RAN, pp. 26–28.
18. Preobrazhenskaya A.A., Smirnov V.P., Zueva K.P., Timofeev P.P. (2013) Mir. Vyzovy global’nogo krizisa. Frantsiya [World. The Challenges of Global Crisis. France]. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, no 11, pp 70–83.
19. Rabotyazhev N.V. (2012) Evropejskaya sotsial-demokratiya v poiskakh adaptatsii k menyayushсhemusya miru [European Social Democratic Movements in Pursuit of Adaptation to a Changing World]. Politiya, no 3, pp. 146–167.
20. Rubinsky Yu.I. (2012) Frantsiya na novom vitke istorii: vybory 2012 goda [A New History Development in France: 2012 Elections]. Sovremennaya Evropa, no 4, pp. 19–33.
21. Rubinsky Yu.I. (2016) Frantsiya: dva s’ezda [France: Two Conventions]. Sovremennaya Evropa, no 2, pp. 87–91.
22. Sortir des Traités Européens. LAEC.fr. Available at: https://laec.fr/chapitre/4/sortirdes-traites-europeens, accessed 8.03.2018.
23. Timofeev P.P. (2017) Frantsuzskij evroskeptitsizm: istoki i sovremennost’ [French Euroscepticism: History and the Present Time]. Outlines of Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, Law, vol. 10, no 1, pp. 53–68.
24. Uznarodov I.M. (2015) Evroskeptitsizm posle krizisa [Euroscepticism after the Crisis]. Sovremennaya Evropa, no 1, pp. 26–36.
25. Varakina А.А. (2009) Sovremennye frantsuzskie partii o Evroparlamente [Contemporary French Parties on the European Parliament]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Seriya 6. Politologiya. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, no 4, pp. 144–150.
26. Vershinin A.A. (2016) Frantsuzskie ul’tralevye na rubezhe vekov [The French Ultra- left at the Turn of the Century]. Sovremennaya Evropa, no 3, pp. 66–78.
27. Vershinin A.A. (2017) «Nepokoryonnyj » Melanshon zakhodit na vtoroj krug [“Unbowed” Melenchon Starts Second Round]. Prezidentskie vybory vo Frantsii- 2017 [Presidential Elections in France in 2017] (eds. Klinova M.V., Kudryavtseva A.K., Timofeev P.P.), Moscow: IMEMO RAN, pp. 38–40.
28. Zvereva T.V. (2017) Frantsiya i budushchee evrointegratsii [France and the Future of European Integration]. Prezidentskie vybory vo Frantsii-2017 [Presidential Elections in France in 2017] (eds. Klinova M.V., Kudryavtseva A.K., Timofeev P.P.), Moscow: IMEMO RAN, pp. 51–55.
Review
For citations:
DOMANOV A.O. Euroscepticism Level of French Parties Determined by the Content-analysis of Their Pre-election Manifestos. Outlines of global transformations: politics, economics, law. 2018;11(3):199-212. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.23932/2542-0240-2018-11-3-199-212
Views:
1178
Email this article 