The Formation of the Soviet Diplomatic Culture (1917–1939)

The article, based on the theory of field of P. Bourdieu, examines the complex evolution of the Soviet diplomatic culture in the interwar period. The idea of dismantling the diplomatic field as such dominated the minds of the Bolsheviks for a relatively short time and was quickly replaced by aspiration for a deep reformatting of the diplomatic field by introducing new practices and ideas about the legitimacy of social and symbolic capital into it. The Bolsheviks’ disillusionment with the prospects of the world revolution started the process of gradually embedding the Soviet foreign policy service in the diplomatic field and adapting to its structures. The assimilation of the appropriate habitus led to the formation of a special ethos among the diplomatic corps, which brought it closer to the Western behavioral model. At the negotiating level, this trend was reflected in the formation of diplomats’ desire to establish long-term relations with capitalist states, even at the cost of political concessions. The corresponding signs were clearly manifested during the Genoa Conference, and fully made themselves felt after M.M.  Litvinov came to the leadership of the NKID (People’s Commissariat for Foreign Affairs of the USSR), under whom the Soviet diplomatic corps acquired the visual features of a special socio-professional group. The most profound integration of the Soviet foreign ministry into the diplomatic field took place in the first half – mid-1930s during the implementation of its collective security policy. However, after 1936, Stalin’s desire to take full control of foreign policy against the background of the general failure of Litvinov’s course in the international arena launched the process of restructuring the NKID, which ended with the formation of the foundations of a new diplomatic culture.

1. Adler-Nissen R. (2014). Symbolic Power in European Diplomacy: The Struggle Between National Foreign Services and the EU’s External Action Service. Review of International Studies, vol. 40, no. 4, pp. 657– 681. DOI: 10.1017/S0260210513000326.

2. Aralov S.I. (1960). Memoirs of a Soviet diplomat (1922–1923). Moscow : Izdatel’stvo Instituta mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy, 222 pp. (in Russian).

3. Bourdieu P. (2007). Sociology of social space. Saint-Petersburg : Aleteya, 288 pp. (in Russian).

4. Bull H. (2002). The anarchical society: A study of order in world politics. New York : Columbia University Press, 329 pp.

5. Carley M.J. (2006). A Soviet Eye on France from the rue de Grenelle in Paris, 1924–1940. Diplomacy & Statecraft, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 295–346.

6. Chuev F.I. (1991). One hundred and forty conversations with Molotov: From the diary of F. Chuev. Moscow : Terra, 623 pp. (in Russian).

7. Churchill W.S. (1986). The Second World War. Vol. 1, The Gathering Storm. New York : Harper Paperbacks, 724 pp.

8. Debo R. (1994). G.V. Chicherin: A Historical Perspective. In: Gorodetsky G. (ed.). Soviet Foreign Policy, 1917–1991: A Retrospective. London : Routledge, pp. 21–29.

9. Desyat’ let… (1927). Ten years of Soviet diplomacy (acts and documents). Moscow : Litizdat Narkomindela, 124 pp. (in Russian).

10. Deutscher I. (2006). Trotsky. An armed prophet. 1879–1921. Moscow : Tsentrpoligraf, 527 pp.

11. Dokumenti… (1957). Foreign Policy Documents, vol. 1. Moscow : Gospolitizdat, 772 pp. (in Russian).

12. Dullin S. (2009). Stalin and His Diplomats: The Soviet Union and Europe, 1930–1939. Moscow : ROSSPEN, 319 pp. (in Russian).

13. Ehrenburg I.G. (2000). Collected works, vol. 7. Moscow : Khudozhestvennaya literature, 861 pp. (in Russian).

14. Erlikhman V.V. (2022). Leonid Krasin. Red lord. Moscow : Veche, 416 pp. (in Russian).

15. Haslam J. (1994). Litvinov, Stalin and the Road Not Taken. In: Gorodetsky G. (ed.). Soviet Foreign Policy, 1917–1991: A Retrospective. London : Routledge, pp. 55–62.

16. Ivanov Yu.V. (2022). The First Soviet Diplomats. NKID RSFSR/USSR. 1917–1941. Moscow : Pero, 464 pp. (in Russian).

17. Jackson P. (2008). Pierre Bourdieu, the “cultural turn” and the practice of international history. Review of International Studies, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 155–181. DOI: 10.1017/S026021050800795X.

18. Khormach I.A. (2020). The Soviet state at the international conference in Genoa on economic and financial issues. April 10 – May 19, 1922. Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya, no. 3, pp. 80–106 (in Russian).

19. Kocho-Williams A. (2012). Russian and Soviet Diplomacy, 1900–39. London : Palgrave Macmillan, 227 pp.

20. Kollontai A.M. (2001). Diplomatic diaries, vol. 1. Moscow : Academia, 527 pp. (in Russian).

21. Kononova M.M. (2002). Activities of diplomats of the tsarist and Provisional governments in 1917–1938. Voprosy istorii, no. 3, pp. 105–118 (in Russian).

22. Lenin V.I. (1968). Complete Works, vol. 21. Moscow : Politizdat, 671 pp. (in Russian).

23. Lenin V.I. (1969). Complete Works, vol. 37, Moscow : Politizdat, 748 pp. (in Russian).

24. Lenin V.I. (1970). Complete Works, vol. 44, Moscow : Politizdat, 725 pp. (in Russian).

25. Maysky I.M. (1964). Memoirs of the Soviet Ambassador. Moscow : Nauka, 462 pp. (in Russian).

26. Mérand F., Pouliot V. (2008). Le monde de Pierre Bourdieu: Éléments pour une théorie sociale des relations internationales. Revue canadienne de science politique, vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 603–625.

27. Nikonov V.A. (2016). Molotov: Our cause is just, vol. 2. Moscow : Molodaya Gvardya, 524 pp. (in Russian).

28. O’Connor T.E. (1991). Georgy Chicherin and Soviet foreign policy, 1918-1930. Moscow : Progress, 320 pp. (in Russian).

29. Ocherki… (2002a). Ivanov I.S. (ed.). Essays on the history of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia, vol. 2. Moscow : OLMA-PRESS, 617 pp. (in Russian).

30. Ocherki… (2002b). Ivanov I.S. (ed.). Essays on the history of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia, vol. 3. Moscow : OLMA-PRESS, 419 pp. (in Russian).

31. Osokina E.A. (1999). Behind the facade of “Stalin’s abundance”. Distribution and market in the supply of the population during the years of industrialization. 1927–1941. Moscow : ROSSPEN, 271 pp. (in Russian).

32. Ostapenko A.I. (2019). Organizational construction of the NKID of the RSFSR in the Petrograd period and the move of the Soviet government to Moscow in March 1918. In: Tuchkov I.I., Belousov L.S. (eds.). The move of the Soviet government to Moscow. On the 100th anniversary of the return of the capital to Moscow. Saint-Petersurg : Aleteya, pp. 137–162 (in Russian).

33. Pope A.U. (1943). Maxim Litvinoff. New York : Secker & Warburg, 530 pp.

34. Poslednyaya sluzhebnaya… (1995). The last memo of G.V. Chicherin. Istochnik, no. 6, pp. 99–112 (in Russian).

35. Pouliot V. (2010). International Security in Practice: The Politics of NATO – Russia Diplomacy. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 290 pp.

36. Sending O.J. (2011). United by difference: Diplomacy as a thin culture. International Journal, vol. 66, no. 3, pp. 643–659. DOI: 10.1177/00207020110660030.

37. Senn A.E. (1974). Diplomacy and Revolution: The Soviet Mission to Switzerland, 1918. Notre Dame, Indiana : Notre Dame University Press, 221 pp.

38. Sheinis Z.S. (1989). Maxim Maksimovich Litvinov: revolutionary, diplomat, man. Moscow : Izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, 430 pp. (in Russian).

39. Sobraniye… (1942). Collection of laws and government orders for 1917–1918. Moscow : Administration of Affairs of the USSR Council of People’s Commissars, 1483 pp. (in Russian).

40. Stone J. (2021). So many butterflies: Isaiah Berlin and the challenge of strategy. Journal of Strategic Studies, vol. 44, no. 5, pp. 640–660. DOI: 10.1080/ 01402390.2019.1612376.

41. The Times Survey of the Foreign Ministries of the World (1982). Steiner Z. (ed.). London : Times Book, 624 pp.

42. V.I. Lenin i VChK… (1975). V.I. Lenin and the Cheka. Collection of documents (1917–1922). Moscow : Politizdat, 679 pp. (in Russian).

43. Vaïsse M. (1985). L’adaptation du Quai d’Orsay aux nouvelles conditions diplomatiques (1919–1939). Revue d’histoire moderne et contemporaine, vol. 32, no. 1, pp. 145–162.

44. Vatlin A.Yu. (2009). Comintern: Ideas, Decisions, destinies. Moscow : ROSSPEN, 2009, 374 pp. (in Russian).

45. Vershinin A.A. (2020). At the origins of Soviet-French military cooperation: the mission of B.M. Simonov in France (1932–1933). Rossiyskaya istoriya, no. 3, pp. 52–66 (in Russian).

46. Watson D. (2004). The Politburo and Foreign Policy in the 1930. In: Rees E.A. (ed.). The Nature of Stalin’s Dictatorship. The Politburo, 1924–1953. Basingstoke, New York : Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 134–167.